Central European Papers 2020, 8(2):65-80 | DOI: 10.25142/cep.2020.007

Regulation of special legal order in Hungary - Constitutional options in the shadow of the COVID crisis -

Dr. István SIMICSKÓ1
1 University of Public Service Üllői út 82, 1083 Budapest, Hungary

States often try to find a way of dealing with social problems and crises by legal institutions. The regulations of special legal order occupy a unique place among the general constitutional rules of the Hungarian legal order. The need of introducing special legal order means that Hungary is in a situation which requires special legal instruments from the state in order to return to the normal operation of the country determined by the normal legal order as soon as possible. The fact that the freely elected legislative power, the National Assembly determines the content and form of the cases when a deviation becomes possible from the general rules is an important pillar of the stability of the democratic state. Based on the principle of proportionality, there are different types of special legal order, consequently the concentration of power is possible only when it is absolute necessary to deal with the situation. Finding the balance between efficiency and the risk of abuse is very important. So special legal order is always temporary and ultimate, which can be applied as an ultima ratio of the legislation in the times of need, but only if their every constitutional conditions are met. Potential threats change constantly, so the regulations of special legal order also need to be updated from time to time.

Keywords: special legal order, qualified period

Zveřejněno: 13. červenec 2021  Zobrazit citaci

ACS AIP APA ASA Harvard Chicago Chicago Notes IEEE ISO690 MLA NLM Turabian Vancouver
István SIMICSKÓ D. Regulation of special legal order in Hungary - Constitutional options in the shadow of the COVID crisis -. Central European Papers. 2020;8(2):65-80. doi: 10.25142/cep.2020.007.
Sdílet...
Stáhnout citaci
  • BibTeX (.bib)
  • Bookends (.ris)
  • EasyBib (.ris)
  • EndNote (.enw)
  • EndNote 8 (.xml)
  • ISI WoS (.isi)
  • Medlars (.medlars)
  • Mendeley (.ris)
  • MODS (.xml)
  • Papers (.ris)
  • RefWorks (.txt)
  • RefManager (.ris)
  • RIS (.ris)
  • MS Word (.xml)
  • Zotero (.ris)
    • Zobrazit celý článek

    Reference

    1. The Fundamental Law of Hungary.
    2. Draft law no. T/2627 with reasoning attached - on the Fundamental Law of Hungary.
    3. Draft law no. T/10416 with reasoning attached - the 6th amendment to the Fundamental Law of Hungary.
    4. Draft law no. T/13647. with reasoning attached - the 9th amendment to the Fundamental Law of Hungary, to the 11. paragraph.
    5. The Act LXIII. of 1912, paragraph 1, on the extraordinary measures in the event of war.
    6. The Act L. of 1914, the first amendment to the the LXVIII. Law Act of 1912 on the provision of war services.
    7. The Act XII. of 1935, paragraphs 1 and 2, on air defence system.
    8. The Act XX. of 1938 on military defence, on the development of economy, on welfare developments and their financial background.
    9. The Act II. of 1939 on national defence.
    10. The Act XX. of 1949 on the Conbstitution of the Hungarian Republic. The Act IV. of 1960, on national defence.
    11. The Act XXXI. of the amendment of the Constitution.
    12. The Act CVII. of 1993, on the amendment of the Constitution. The Act XXXIV. of 1994, on the police force.
    13. The Act CIV. of 2004, the amendment of Law Act of 1949 on the Constitution of the Hungarian Republic.
    14. The Act CXII. of 2011 on national defence and on the Hungarian Defence Force, and on the rules to be introduced in special legal order.
    15. The Act CXXVIII. of 2011 on disaster management and on the amendments of laws attached.
    16. Government Decree 177/2013. (4 June). Government regulation on the declaration of state of danger and the measures required.
    17. Government Decree 40/2020 (11 March) on the declaration of state of danger.
    18. Government Decree 478/2020. (3 November) on the declaration of state of danger.
    19. The ninth amendment of the Fundamental Law (22 December 2022, paragraph 52, subparagraph (3).
    20. BARTKÓ, Róbert: Az illegális migráció és a terrorizmus kapcsolata az EUROPOL és a FRONTEX jelentéseire tekintettel. (The relation of illegal migration and terrorism based on reports by EUROPOL and FRONTEX).
    21. CSINK, Lóránt: "Mikor legyen a jogrend különleges?" in: IustumAequumSalutare, 2017, 4, 7-16. ("When should the legal order be special?").
    22. FARKAS, Ádám, Az állam fegyveres védelmi rendszerének kérdései a kortárs fenyegetések tükrében, in: Katonai Jogi és Hadijogi Szemle, 2015, 1, 140-142. (The questions of the state armed defence system in the in the reflection of contemporary threats).
    23. FARKAS, Ádám - KÁDÁR, Pál: A különleges jogrendi szabályozás fejlődése és katonai védelmi vonatkozása. In: FARKAS Ádám - KÁDÁR Pál (szerk.): Magyarország katonai védelmének közjogi alapjai. 2016. Zrínyi Kiadó, Budapest 303-307. Development of special legal order and its aspects of defense).
    24. JAKAB, András - Till Szabolcs: X. Alkotmányvédelem - Különleges jogrend, JAK - PPKE, 1033-1072.
    25. JAKAB, András (szerk.): Az Alkotmány kommentárja I. Századvég Kiadó, Budapest, 2009. 231-666. (Commentary of the Constitution vol. I.).
    26. JAKAB, András: Az új Alaptörvény keletkezése és gyakorlati következményei. Budapest, HVG-Orac, 2011. (The emergence and practical consequences of the new Fundamental Law).
    27. KÁDÁR, Pál: A különleges jogrendi szabályozás megújítása és a Magyar Katonai Jogi és Hadijogi Társaság, in: Katonai Jogi és Hadijogi Szemle, 2020, 4, 7-34. (The revision of the regulations of special legal order and the Society of Hungarian Military Law and War Legislation).
    28. LAKATOS, László: A különleges jogrend és a honvédelem szabályozása, MTA Law WorkingPapers, 2014, 49. (Special legal order and the regulation of national defence).
    29. NÉMETH, Hajnalka: Spanyolnátha. A világméretű rejtélyes járványról egy kicsit másképp, in: Better Responsibility Initiative, 2019-2020. (Spanish Flu. Reflections on the Mysterious Pandemia from a Different Viewpoint).
    30. ŐSZE, Áron: Analízis a magyar különleges jogrendi szabályozás hatékonyságáról, Diskurzus - The Academic Journal of the Lajos Batthyany College of the Ferenc Deák Faculty of Law at the University of István Széchenyi 8, 2, 33-44. (Analysis of the effectiveness of the Hungarian legislation of special legal order).
    31. SIMICSKÓ, István: A terrorizmus elleni védelem fokozása a különleges jogrendi kategóriák bővítésével, in: Hadtudomány, 2016, 3-4. 113. (The enhancement of defence against terrorism with increasing the categories of special legal order).
    32. SIMICSKÓ, István: A terrorizmus elleni védelem fokozása a különleges jogrendi kategóriák bővítésével, in: Hadtudomány, 2016, 3-4, 113. (The enhancement of defence against terrorism with the enlargement of legal categories).
    33. SIMICSKÓ, István: Az országvédelem és országmozgósítás szervezeti, hatásköri, irányítási rendszere minősített időszakokban, Doktori értekezés, ZMNE-HTK 2008, 24. o.
    34. SIMICSKÓ, István: A hibrid hadviselés előzményei és aktualitásai, Hadtudomány, 2017, 3-4. (The precedents of hybrid warfare and its actualities).
    35. TILL, Szabolcs: A különleges jogrendi kategóriarendszer egyszerűsítésének jövőbeli esélyei, in: IustumAequumSalutare, 2017, 4, 55-75. (Future opportunities of the simplification of the category system of special legal order).
    36. TILL, Szabolcs: "Különleges jogrend" in: Internetes Jogtudományi Enciklopedia, Jakab András - Fekete Balázs (eds.), 2019. [37] ("Online Encyclopedia of Legal Science").

    Tento článek je publikován v režimu tzv. otevřeného přístupu k vědeckým informacím (Open Access), který je distribuován pod licencí Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (CC BY 4.0), která umožňuje distribuci, reprodukci a změny, pokud je původní dílo řádně ocitováno. Není povolena distribuce, reprodukce nebo změna, která není v souladu s podmínkami této licence.


    Zpět na obsah